Tag Archives: Dave Matthews

Does the Monster in “Don’t Drink the Water” Realize He’s the Villain?

Watch the video of “Don’t Drink the Water”

You probably think so. I’m not so sure. Dave Matthews said the line “Don’t drink the water” is about looking back at what we’ve done. Sometimes when he sings the song, those lines reflect a glorification of what was done, and other times it carries a tinge of regret, or wonder.

That’s one of the beauties of musical performance—it can be a little different every time, and this gives us room to consider it freshly.

My fresh look considers how this song reflects that we tend to overlook our own evils while condemning others’.

It is impossible to hear this song and think the villain is anything but a villain. It is sung with such vocal darkness, and with lyrics like “You have been banished/Your land is gone/And given to me” and “I will bury you,” and then “you’re all dead now/And I will live with my justice,” it is clearly wicked.

Yet, it finishes with an acknowledgment that what he did polluted his own water, spoiling a source of life and cleanliness and healing. The villain glorifies his wickedness, calling his erasure of other cultures “justice,” and then looks back and sees the blood he’s spilled, and then . . . what?

When I first heard the song, I didn’t realize it was the villain’s perspective because I didn’t expect Dave Matthews to be the villain!

But let’s be honest, we have all justified our actions while knowing that they were unjustifiable.

So I ask you this: when we listen to this song, do we think that the villain is someone else? You should know, Dave Matthews has identified himself as the villain.

What happens when we are the Monster who erases peoples and cultures and then looks back at the blood in the water? Do we reconsider what we’ve done, or continue to justify?

Some of us justify. Ben Shapiro claims the genocide and slavery committed by our colonial past is justified by European ideals, including “property rights, due process of law, capitalism, freedom of religion.” He conveniently forgets that property rights and due process never applied to everyone, only the conquerors, and thus, history is written (and erased) by the victors. There’s blood in those waters.

Yet, isn’t it natural for us to write a moral agenda validating the horrors we’ve committed?

At first, I was shocked at Ben Shapiro’s argument. But he voices what a significant portion of America believes, likely the same portion that went to war to defend slavery. It’s an American perspective.

Now here I go sliding toward a political agenda, tsk-tsk. Dave Matthews does not. He doesn’t want to be political, he “just [doesn’t] want people to get shot for going to school or for going to the office.” And if he’s not politicizing this, then neither should we.

So why don’t we just listen to the song, slip into the skin of the villain, embrace what we’ve done, look at the blood in the water, and consider . . . what next?